Passkeys vs SMS: Is the Era of Verification Codes Coming to an End?
By Adam Sawicki
Cloud Security Architect at Big 4 IT Consulting Firm • FIDO Alliance Contributor • 8 years experience in authentication
💡 Industry Insider Perspective:
Apple, Google, and Microsoft didn't just announce passkeys - they declared war on passwords AND SMS verification. As someone implementing these systems for Fortune 500 companies, I can tell you: SMS-based 2FA will be deprecated by 2028. Here's the technical and business reality.
The Perfect Storm: Why Now?
Three converging forces are killing SMS verification:
- Security Failures: SIM swapping attacks increased 400% 2023-2025
- Cost Pressure: SMS verification costs businesses $0.01-$0.08 per message
- Regulatory Push: NIST deprecated SMS for 2FA in 2024, EU following in 2026
- User Experience: 67% of users hate typing 6-digit codes
- Technical Maturity: FIDO2/WebAuthn now supported by 92% of browsers
Technical Deep Dive: How Passkeys Actually Work
Passkey Authentication Flow:
- Registration: Website generates cryptographic challenge
- Device Binding: Your device (phone/laptop) creates key pair
- Private Key Storage: Never leaves secure element (TPM/SE)
- Public Key Registration: Sent to website for future verification
- Authentication: Website sends challenge, device signs with private key
- Verification: Website verifies signature with stored public key
Key difference: No secrets transmitted during authentication. Compare to SMS where code travels through 5+ systems.
Head-to-Head Comparison: Passkeys vs SMS 2FA
| Criteria | SMS Verification | Passkeys (FIDO2) | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phishing Resistance | Zero - codes work on any site | Complete - bound to specific domain | Passkeys |
| SIM Swap Attack | Vulnerable | Immune | Passkeys |
| Network Dependency | Requires cellular/WiFi | Works offline after setup | Passkeys |
| Cost per Auth | $0.01 - $0.08 | $0.000001 (electricity) | Passkeys |
| Setup Time | 30 seconds | 45 seconds | Tie |
| Auth Time | 10-30 seconds | 2-5 seconds | Passkeys |
| Device Support | All phones | ~85% of devices (growing) | SMS (for now) |
| Recovery | SMS to new number | Cloud sync or backup codes | Passkeys |
The 5-Year Adoption Timeline
2024-2025: Foundation
- Apple, Google, Microsoft announce passkey support
- Major password managers add passkey storage
- Early adopters: PayPal, eBay, Best Buy
- Market penetration: 5% of major sites
2026 (Now): Acceleration
- NIST formal deprecation of SMS for government use
- Banking sector pilot programs
- Enterprise SSO integration (Okta, Azure AD)
- Google making passkeys default for Google accounts
- Market penetration: 15-20% of major sites
2027: Tipping Point
- EU Digital Identity Wallet mandates passkey support
- Major banks complete migration
- Apple requiring passkeys for App Store dev accounts
- SMS verification costs increase 300% (carrier pricing)
- Market penetration: 40-50% of major sites
2028: Dominance
- SMS verification removed from PCI DSS compliance
- Insurance companies discount cyber insurance for passkey use
- Legacy system sunset begins
- Market penetration: 70%+ of major sites
2029+: Legacy Phase
- SMS verification only for edge cases (landlines, developing markets)
- Passkeys as default, everything else as fallback
- New authentication methods emerge (biometric continuous auth)
- Market penetration: 90%+ of major sites
Business Impact Analysis
For Enterprises (Cost Savings)
Example: Bank with 10M customers, 2 authentications/month:
| Cost Component | SMS Verification | Passkeys | Annual Savings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Per Auth Cost | $0.03 (bulk rate) | $0.000001 | $7.19M |
| Support Calls | 5% of users (500k calls) | 1% of users (100k calls) | $12M (at $30/call) |
| Fraud Losses | $2M annually | $200k annually | $1.8M |
| Total Annual | $21M+ | $1.2M | $19.8M+ |
For Users (Experience Improvement)
- No more typing codes: Face ID/Touch ID/Fingerprint
- Cross-device sync: Start on laptop, approve on phone
- No cellular required: Airplane mode authentication
- Automatic phishing protection: Won't work on fake sites
- Disaster recovery: Cloud backup or printed codes
The Compatibility Challenge
The elephant in the room: What about users without compatible devices?
📱 Device Compatibility Reality (2026):
- Smartphones: iPhone (iOS 16+), Android (8+ with Google Play Services)
- Computers: Windows 10+, macOS Ventura+, ChromeOS 96+
- Coverage: ~85% of active devices in developed markets
- Gap: Older Android phones, corporate locked devices, developing markets
- Solution: Hybrid approach with SMS/TOTP fallback until 2028
Implementation Guide for Businesses
For companies planning migration (simplified):
- Phase 1 (Q1 2026): Add passkey as OPTIONAL 2FA method alongside SMS
- Phase 2 (Q3 2026): Encourage migration (emails, incentives, better UX for passkey users)
- Phase 3 (Q1 2027): Make passkey DEFAULT for new users
- Phase 4 (Q3 2027): Show warnings for SMS users, highlight risks
- Phase 5 (Q1 2028): Deprecate SMS for all but legacy/high-risk transactions
User Action Plan: What You Should Do Now
🎯 Immediate User Actions:
- Test passkeys today: Set up on Google Account (accounts.google.com)
- Check device compatibility: iPhone with Face ID/Touch ID, Android with fingerprint
- Prioritize migration: Banking → Email → Social Media → Everything else
- Keep backup methods: Don't disable SMS until you have 2+ passkey devices
- Educate family: Help parents/grandparents transition (it's actually easier for them)
The SMS Verification Industry Impact
What happens to the $15B SMS verification industry?
- Carriers: Lose $3-5B in revenue by 2028
- Gateway providers: Twilio, Vonage pivot to identity verification APIs
- Cost structure: Prices increase as volume decreases (vicious cycle)
- New markets: SMS shifts to marketing, alerts (non-critical)
- Legacy support: Government, healthcare, developing markets last holdouts
Future Beyond Passkeys: What's Next?
Passkeys aren't the endgame - they're the foundation:
| Technology | Timeframe | Improvement Over Passkeys |
|---|---|---|
| Continuous Authentication | 2027-2029 | Behavioral biometrics (typing, mouse movements) |
| Decentralized Identity | 2028-2030 | Self-sovereign identity (you control credentials) |
| Quantum-Resistant Crypto | 2030-2035 | Post-quantum cryptography standards |
| Biometric Fusion | 2026-2028 | Multiple biometrics + liveness detection |
Conclusion: The Inevitable Transition
SMS verification had a good run - 25 years as the dominant second factor. But in technology, nothing lasts forever. The combination of security failures, cost pressures, and better alternatives has sealed its fate.
As someone implementing these systems: The transition will be faster than most people expect. When Google makes something default, when Apple builds it into iOS, when banks start migrating - that's the beginning of the end.
Your action items: Start using passkeys today on services that support them. Encourage your workplace to adopt them. Help less technical family members make the switch. And say goodbye to typing 6-digit codes - that era is ending.
Author: Adam Sawicki • Cloud Security Architect • Last updated: February 15, 2026
Related Articles
Technical analysis of SMS-based 2FA vulnerabilities and secure alternatives.
Complete technical guide for developers implementing SMS verification systems.